Skip to main content

Homemade Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe

The Best Peanut Butter for reals!

Your Key To Success -- The Soft Ball Stage

Don't let candy making scare you. Once you learn the basics, making candy can become rather easy. I will make two or three batches of this recipe over baking a cake from scratch every day of the week. If you can boil water you can do this.

The process is just like cooking most other things. When not cooked fully, it will be soggy. If you cook it too long, it will be dry. Sometimes it takes a batch or two to figure it all out.

There is a secret, though, and it is called the soft ball stage. This stage is crucial for proper setting of your candies. This is reached at between 235 to 240 degrees Fahrenheit. At this stage, if you place your sugar syrup mixture you are cooking into a cold glass of water, it will form on it's own into a ball. If you place this ball in your hand the ball will flatten out. If you can master this technique, you can make any flavor fudge.

Old fashioned stovetop peanut butter fudge is so easy to make and I know your family will love it!  Homemade Stove top Fudge Recipe
Old fashioned stovetop peanut butter fudge is so easy to make
and I know your family will love it!

Softball Stage Explained

print recipe

Homemade Stovetop Peanut Butter Fudge
I am so glad I have this family recipe for peanut butter fudge. It is a favorite at parties and other gatherings. It's so easy, sometimes I make it when my husband and I want a sweet treat. My grandfather grew up in an old coal mining town in West Virginia. This is his families recipe.
  • 3 cups granulated sugar
  • 3/4 cup milk, do not use skim
  • 1 and a 1/2 cups peanut butter, smooth or chunky, use a little more if it's chunky
  • 1 tablespoon tablespoon butter
  • 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
  • pinch salt
Butter a 9x9 pan.Grab a cup of cold water but this will not be mixed into your fudge. Start by mixing your sugar and milk together in a saucepan with no heat. Compile all of the other ingredients and have them ready, you will not have time to measure anything after the syrup is finished cooking. When everything is ready and set up, turn of the burner between low and medium. Do not stop stirring and bring the syrup to a hard boil. When the temperature read 235 degrees Fahrenheit, drop a bit of your mixture into your cold water. If it forms a nice ball it is ready. If not, continue boiling but not for long.When you reach soft ball stage, turn off heat and all of your other ingredients. Mix well, and place the mixture into your buttered pan.Let set and then cut into small squares.
Prep time: Cook time: Total time: Yield: 25 Squares

If you decide to make this awesome dessert, make sure you let me know now it turned out in the comments.


  1. Best stove top recipe yet for peanut butter fudge. I've tried something similar that I came up with on my own. Turns out I was using too much butter.
    I make old fashioned fudge a couple times a year over the last 15 years, so I've had lots of practice.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

5 Interesting Non Traditional Crochet Square Patterns

I absolutely love to crochet squares.  The very first crochet pattern I ever learned by heart was the granny square.  Even now, years and years later, when I am bored and I just want to crochet for the pure joy of crochet, the granny square is my go to pattern.  I know many other crocheters out there feel the same way and that's why crocheting squares is so popular.  There are so many square patterns out there, a crocheter could never complete them all in a life time.  I decided to search up a few really awesome squares and I felt were unique but still reminded me of that classic pattern I love so much.  These are the patterns that I found.  The stained glass afghan pattern costs a $1.99 but the rest of the patterns listed here are completely free and they are featured on the blogs of other designers.  All of these designs are now additions to my crochet bucket list.

Pink Pineapple Doily Free Crochet Pattern

Hello and Greetings Everyone I know I haven't been around a lot to post lately but with the holidays, well everyone knows how that goes... But I am back and I have a new crochet pattern to share, it's called the Pink Pineapple Doily. The original pattern appeared in 1951 in the publication Star Book No. 87, Doilies, Doilies, Doilies. For a printer friendly and editable version of this post, scroll down to the bottom and click the button that says "Print Friendly." I am absolutely in love with this doily. It looks like a very complex pattern but if your are just starting to make doilies and other crochet goods this is a great pattern to learn how to read other, more complex patterns. Decorating your home with crochet doilies can add a touch of vintage and handmade charm to any space. Start by considering the size and color of the doilies you would like to use. Crochet doilies come in a variety of sizes and colors, so you can choose to match your existing

Decorate Your Home With 15+ Free Christmas Crochet Patterns

Free Christmas Crochet Patterns It's just too much fun to find all of these amazing free crochet patterns.  My last round up was a collection of free crochet tree patterns but this collection is going to be a little bit of everything to bring your home some holiday cheer this season.  All of these patterns are free at the time of posting but some of them are specials for the 2014 holiday season and some of these patterns may not be available for free in the future so make sure you download them all now! Special Note -- I do not own any of the pictures on this post.  Please do not use these images with out first contacting the original owner,  Thanks and enjoy all of these wonderful patterns.  The image credit links point to the designers Ravelry page or somewhere similar where you can see more of their amazing make sure you check those out too!